Skip to main content

Carpet Shampoo vs Steam Cleaner: Uncovering the Best Deep Clean for Your Home

Carpet cleaning: a simple task with a complex choice – carpet shampoo vs steam cleaner. Whether you’re dealing with stubborn stains or regular dirt build-up, selecting the right cleaning method can feel like a daunting task. Is carpet shampooing more effective? Or perhaps steam cleaning is the way to go? Each has its strengths and weaknesses, and understanding them is key to achieving that deep, thorough clean we all crave for our carpets.

Key Takeaways

  • Carpet Shampooing and Steam Cleaning are effective ways to deep clean carpets, with each having advantages and drawbacks.

  • Assess your carpet’s condition, consider cleaning frequency and weigh the costs/benefits of each method to determine which is most suitable for individual needs.

  • The top rated carpet shampooers & steam cleaners on the market in 2023 include Hoover Smartwash Automatic Carpet Cleaner, Ewbank Steam Dynamo & Bissell Little Green Portable Carpet Cleaner 1400B.

Carpet Shampooing Unveiled

Carpet shampooing machine in action

Carpet shampooing, a time-tested method, is well-regarded for its ability to remove dirt and stains. This process involves a carpet shampooing machine which introduces a cleaning solution into your carpet fibers, resulting in foam that targets the unwanted particles. But as powerful as it can be, carpet shampooing comes with its share of challenges too.

How Carpet Shampooing Works

The workings of carpet shampooing are initiated as soon as you switch on the machine. A brush introduces a shampoo solution, comprising of water and specialized carpet cleaning soaps and detergents, into the carpet fibers, creating a foam that effectively targets dirt particles and stains. As the brush agitates the carpet fibers, the cleaning solution is evenly distributed, and the foam captures and absorbs the dirt embedded deep within the carpet fibers.

However, not all detergents are made alike. Using regular laundry detergent might be tempting, but it’s not suitable for carpet cleaning. Specialized cleaning solutions designed specifically for carpet cleaning are recommended for carpet shampooing to ensure the effectiveness and safety of the process. After the shampooing and brushing process, the loosened dirt particles are eliminated from the carpet fibers using the suction power of a vacuum cleaner integrated into the carpet shampooing machine.

Benefits of Carpet Shampooing

Carpet shampooing has numerous advantages. Its primary benefit is its ability to deliver a deep, penetrating clean that effectively eliminates dirt, grease, and stains from your carpets. Regular carpet cleaning, including both shampooing and steam cleaning, is essential for maintaining the appearance and longevity of your carpets.

Notably, carpet shampooing is particularly efficient in eliminating:

  • Water-soluble stains, like those from food and beverages, mud and dirt, and water-based spots

  • Pollutants and allergens that are confined in the carpet, which can have adverse effects on the air quality within your home

  • Pet odors and allergens due to the use of shampoos specifically designed for pet odors and dander

Carpet shampooing, often performed by professional carpet cleaners, has the potential to enhance indoor air quality and is a great option for pet owners seeking clean carpets.

Lastly, by removing dirt, dust, and other particles that can degrade the carpet fibers over time, carpet shampooing can potentially extend your carpet’s usable life by several years.

Drawbacks of Carpet Shampooing

Even though carpet shampooing has numerous benefits, it also has its share of drawbacks. One common issue is carpet residue after shampooing. This can be caused by wicking, rapid resoiling, excessive moisture retention in the carpet, and the presence of soapy residue.

Additionally, carpet shampooing can result in yellowing due to a reaction known as phenolic yellowing. This reaction is triggered when the carpet is cleaned using substances with a high pH level or detergents with a pH exceeding 10. The application of these cleaning agents can induce yellow discoloration in the carpet.

Steam Cleaning Carpets Demystified

Steam cleaning process with high-pressure steam

Now, let’s explore steam cleaning, a technique that employs high-temperature water under high pressure for efficient carpet cleaning. This method’s effectiveness is derived from the combination of high temperature and high pressure using pure water. But as with carpet shampooing, steam cleaning has its own set of pros and cons.

How Steam Cleaning Works

Steam cleaning is centered around the utilization of a steam cleaner. It functions by heating water to generate steam, which is then injected into the carpet fibers at elevated temperature and pressure to remove dirt particles and stains. The resulting mixture is then extracted into a receptacle through a high-suction hose. Steam clean carpets is an effective method to maintain their appearance and longevity.

High-pressure, heated water vapor in steam cleaning, also known as the hot water extraction method, works by:

  • Loosening and breaking down dirt

  • Helping to saponify dirt, grease, and grime

  • Penetrating deep into fabrics and surfaces

  • Effectively lifting and removing stubborn stains and bacteria

The recommended temperature for the water used in steam cleaning carpets is between 200°F to 230°F to ensure effective cleaning without causing damage to the carpet fibers.

While the typical duration required to steam clean an average-sized carpeted room is approximately 15-20 minutes, this timeframe may vary depending on the room’s dimensions and the type of steam cleaner being utilized.

Benefits of Steam Cleaning

Steam cleaning comes with a wide array of advantages, including:

  • Eliminating germs, allergens, and bacteria without the use of harsh chemicals

  • Effectively addressing tough stains and odors

  • Ensuring a comprehensive and deep cleaning

What sets steam cleaning apart is its eco-friendliness. By using only hot water and high pressure for carpet cleaning, it eliminates the need for harsh chemicals. This method not only reduces water usage but also helps in enhancing indoor air quality by minimizing the release of potentially harmful substances.

Additionally, steam cleaning provides a more thorough cleaning by utilizing steam to deeply penetrate carpet fibers, effectively eliminating stains, odors, dirt buildup, and residual substances left by other cleaning methods.

Drawbacks of Steam Cleaning

Despite its general effectiveness, steam cleaning does have some shortcomings. One major drawback is its potential lack of effectiveness on set-in stains. These types of stains may not be fully removed by steam cleaning alone.

Excessive water usage in steam cleaning can also result in the development of mold and mildew, leading to damage to the carpet and posing significant health hazards. Improper steam cleaning can also lead to fiber deterioration or discoloration. The impact of steam cleaning on the color and texture of carpets can be quite significant if not executed correctly. Using incorrect techniques can result in discoloration and damage to the carpet.

Comparing Carpet Shampooing and Steam Cleaning

Comparison of carpet shampooing and steam cleaning

Having unraveled each method’s basics, let’s proceed to a comparative evaluation of carpet shampooing and steam cleaning, emphasizing their stain removal efficiency, drying time, and influence on carpet fibers.

Effectiveness in Removing Stains

Both carpet shampooing and steam cleaning are viable methods for stain removal. Carpet shampooing is particularly effective for heavy stains, while steam cleaning is particularly adept at tackling stubborn stains that necessitate the use of detergents. To decide whether to shampoo or steam clean your carpet, consider the type of stains you’re dealing with.

Steam cleaning is quite effective in the removal of various types of carpet stains. The application of high-temperature steam in conjunction with specific cleaning solutions disintegrates and lifts stains from carpet fibers and effectively eradicates odors by eliminating the bacteria and enzymes responsible for them. However, there may be instances where certain stains persist despite the application of steam cleaning.

Drying Time and Moisture

The drying time for carpets differs between shampooing and steam cleaning. The typical drying time for carpet shampooing ranges from 6 to 10 hours, while the average drying time for steam cleaned carpets is usually 6-12 hours. However, in regions with high humidity, steam-cleaned carpets may require up to 24 hours to fully dry.

Proper drying is crucial in both methods to prevent potential issues such as:

  • Growth of mold or mildew

  • The carpet feeling sticky or attracting additional dirt

  • Prolonged moisture, which can result in water stains, mold, and mildew

  • Stains caused by placing furniture on wet carpets

The potential moisture-related issues that may arise from carpet shampooing include:

  • The development of mold and mildew

  • The risk of slips and falls

  • Water damage to the subfloor

  • The presence of dirty water in the shampooer chamber.

Impact on Carpet Fibers and Color

The impact on carpet fibers and color also varies between the two methods. Carpet shampooing can leave a chemical residue that weakens fibers and causes brittleness if used excessively, leading to fading and damage to delicate fabrics. Improper steam cleaning may result in fiber deterioration or discoloration, potentially leading to mold and mildew growth if the carpet remains excessively wet, or weakening the fibers if aggressive chemicals or high temperatures are used.

Specific carpet fibers such as twisted and looped fibers commonly found in Berber carpets can be more impacted by both shampooing and steam cleaning due to their higher retention of water, dirt, and stains. Certain materials may not withstand the high heat of steam cleaning effectively, highlighting the importance of considering the carpet fiber type when selecting a cleaning method.

Choosing the Right Method for Your Needs

Factors to consider when choosing a cleaning method

With a better understanding of what each cleaning method involves, how do you decide which is the best fit for your home? The answer lies in understanding your carpet’s condition, considering your cleaning frequency, and weighing the costs and benefits.

Assessing Your Carpet’s Condition

The first step is to assess the condition of your carpet. Look for indications of wear and tear such as:

  • Worn-down tracks

  • Rips

  • Significant wear and tear

  • Matting

  • Loss of shape

  • Fiber breakdown

  • Dirtiness

  • Staining

  • Color loss

  • Fading

The nature of stains on a carpet can be identified by analyzing their location, appearance, and smell. Stains are categorized as water-based, oil-based, or protein-based, depending on the substance responsible for the stain. It is advisable to regularly assess the condition of your carpet, ideally every 6 to 12 months, to uphold its cleanliness and appearance.

The age of a carpet does not have a direct impact on its cleaning requirements. However, older carpets may be more prone to wear and tear.

Considering Your Cleaning Frequency

Next, consider how often you need to clean your carpets. Professional carpet cleaning is typically recommended every 12 to 18 months, but this can vary based on the presence of pets and children in the household. Consistent cleaning can contribute to prolonging their lifespan by eliminating dirt and grime that may cause degradation of the carpet fibers over time.

If you have high-traffic areas that require more frequent deep cleaning, then owning a carpet cleaner may be more cost-effective. On the other hand, low-traffic areas may be adequately maintained with less frequent professional cleanings or steam cleanings.

It’s also worth noting that steam cleaning is considered more suitable for frequent carpet cleaning, while shampooing may be more suitable for less frequent cleaning as it is less efficient in removing loose dirt.

Weighing the Costs and Benefits

Lastly, weigh the costs and benefits of carpet shampooing and steam cleaning. The cost of professional carpet shampooing is usually around $165 for areas under 1,000 square feet, while professional steam cleaning costs can vary significantly, ranging from $85 to $259, depending on the size of the space and the number of rooms.

It’s also important to consider the rental cost for a carpet shampooer, which typically ranges from $30 to $95 per day, versus a steam cleaner, which can vary from $30 to $550 for different rental periods. If you’re considering purchasing a carpet shampooer, the cost ranges from approximately $100 to upwards of $500, depending on the model and its features.

Top Carpet Shampooers and Steam Cleaners on the Market

Top carpet cleaning equipment on the market

Having discussed all the essential aspects of carpet cleaning, let’s examine some of the leading carpet shampooers and steam cleaners available on the market. Whether you’re leaning towards shampooing or steam cleaning, there’s a machine out there that’s perfect for your needs.

Best Carpet Shampooers

The top-rated carpet shampooers for 2023 include the Hoover Smartwash Automatic Carpet Cleaner, Bissell ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus Carpet Cleaner, Bissell JetScrub 25299 Upright Pet Carpet Cleaner, and Bissell Big Green. Among them, the Hoover SmartWash Pet is particularly popular, featuring automatic cleaning technology, HeatForce power for faster drying, FlexForce power brushes, Stain Pretreat wand, a spacious water tank capacity, and a user-friendly design.

As for the Bissell ProHeat 2X Revolution Max, it is recognized for:

  • Its superior cleaning performance

  • Multiple cleaning modes

  • An exceptional attachment set

  • Advanced heat technology

  • Superior suction power

All of these features work together to elevate cleaning outcomes.

Best Steam Cleaners

On the steam cleaning front, the top-rated steam cleaners for carpets include:

  • Ewbank Steam Dynamo Steam Cleaner

  • Black+Decker 7-in-1 Multipurpose Steam Cleaner

  • Karcher SC5 easyFix Premium Steam Cleaner

  • Bissell ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Carpet Cleaner

  • Bissell Little Green Portable Carpet Cleaner 1400B.

These steam cleaners stand out due to their unique features. For example, the Bissell SteamShot Hard Surface Steam Cleaner functions as a handheld steamer or mop, and the Black+Decker Multipurpose Steam Cleaner also serves as a handheld steamer or mop with 18 attachments.

The McCulloch Heavy-Duty Steam Cleaner, a truck mounted steam cleaner, is praised for its versatility and deep cleaning proficiency, among other features enhancing their functionality across multiple surfaces.


In conclusion, both carpet shampooing and steam cleaning have their unique strengths and weaknesses. Carpet shampooing provides a deep clean and is particularly effective for heavy stains, while steam cleaning is an eco-friendly option that sanitizes your carpets and is better suited for frequent cleaning. The best method for you will depend on your carpet’s condition, your cleaning frequency, and your budget. With a clear understanding of these two methods, you’re now equipped to make an informed decision that will keep your carpets looking their best.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it better to steam clean or shampoo carpets?

Shampooing carpets is usually more successful in removing set-in stains, however steam cleaning with ZeroRenz Zr Water® can be just as effective while also leaving behind no residue for longer lasting cleanliness.

Is a carpet shampooer the same as a steam cleaner?

No, a carpet shampooer is not the same as a steam cleaner. A steam cleaner utilizes high-temperature steam to sanitize and disinfect surfaces, whereas a carpet shampooer uses detergent and water with a rotating brush to loosen dirt in the carpet fibers.

What are the disadvantages of steam carpet cleaning?

Steam cleaning can damage carpets by reducing the lifespan of fibers, forcing dirt and debris further into the pile, leaving behind chemical residues, causing colors to fade, and making it difficult for carpets to dry properly.

What is the most effective carpet cleaning method?

Steam cleaning is the most effective method for cleaning carpets, as it removes over 90% of dirt and bacteria and stubborn stains. Dry cleaning is also an option for a quicker result.

What is the typical cost of professional carpet shampooing and steam cleaning?

Professional carpet shampooing typically costs around $165 for areas under 1,000 square feet, while KD Carpet Cleaning says steam cleaning costs can vary significantly ranging from $85 to $259 or more.

KD Carpet Cleaning Logo

Ready for Your Next Cleaning? Contact Us Today!